Insane In The Membrane: Arguing Against The Forcible Medication of Mentally Ill Pre-Trial Defendants
نویسنده
چکیده
منابع مشابه
Beyond competence and sanity: the influence of pretrial evaluation on case disposition.
A preliminary investigation of the impact of pretrial evaluations of trial competence and legal insanity, and the variables that mediate case outcomes is reported. Twenty-four percent of defendants evaluated as incompetent to stand trial were found competent by the court or were tried without the question of competence being adjudicated. Charges were dropped in more than half of the cases in wh...
متن کاملThe differential impact of deinstitutionalization on white and nonwhite defendants found incompetent to stand trial.
Previous studies have reported that state mental hospital deinstitutionalization has resulted in the processing of the mentally ill through the criminal justice system. Using pre- and postdeinstitutionalization samples of defendants found incompetent to stand trial (IST) selected from three states, this study examines changes in the mental health and arrest histories of white and nonwhite ISTs....
متن کاملA clinical evaluation of maximum security hospital patients by staff and independent psychiatric consultants.
The psychiatric evaluation of mentally ill offenders and defendants has become a major task at the crossroads of the Criminal Justice and Mental Health Systems. Criminal courts, often burdened and backlogged, are further handicapped in the trial and sentencing of criminal offenders and defendants by the lack of readily available, uniform, high quality psychiatric and psychological diagnostic se...
متن کاملCommentary: Punishing the unpunishable--the abuse of psychiatry to confine those we love to hate.
I commend John Melville and David Naimark for their commentary in this issue of the Journal demonstrating how the guilty but mentally ill (GBMI) verdict perverts the insanity defense by encouraging jurors to find insane defendants guilty (but mentally ill) and by imposing punishment on those found GBMI that is more severe than would have been imposed on them if they had simply been found guilty...
متن کاملAdjusting Treatment for an Inmate-Patient Receiving Medication Involuntarily.
Correctional psychiatrists can pursue authorization for forcible medication of pretrial detainees housed in a federal prison hospital through two pathways: an administrative process based upon the U.S. Supreme Court decision in Washington v. Harper and a judicial process founded on the Court's ruling in Sell v. United States. The pathway associated with Harper pertains to the involuntary treatm...
متن کامل